To cure some, to relieve often, to comfort always
Friday, October 20th, 2006So our ‘Disease and Culture Prejudice’ finally started today (after 1 month U starts officially). The reason was understandable as our form teacher for the subject was our ex-headmaster and he went famous because of this lesson.
Common mentality of Taiwanese a few decades ago was to fight to go into Taiwan National University and thereafter pursue their further education in America. About 80% of those who hold a master’s degree and above have been to the States, and maybe 40% of American Asian population are Taiwanese. So our prof. Mr. Lai Qi-Wan pursued his neuro specialist in Minnesolta, and due to his exposure to countless caring doctors, he eventually have his own personalised idea of being more than a doctor.
Of the many stories he told us today, I find the one regarding Dr. David Landsborough III most touching. Dr. Landsborough was an Englihsman who single-handedly founded the Changhua Christian Hospital in (obviously) Changhua during 1928. In 1928, a thirteen-year-old boy named Chou Jin
Yao from a poor peasant family in Shengang had a non-healing, life-threatening
leg wound. Exemplifying Christian love, Dr. Landsborough operated on the boy
and engrafted four strips of skin, donated by Mrs. Landsborough, onto the boy’s
wound. Afterwards, he and Mrs. Landsborough also provided for the boy’s
education to become a pastor. Thus “love was sown into the heart as the skin
was grafted onto the body.” Indeed, this “Skin Slice of Love” story has deeply moved
and inspired the medical community within and out of the hospital.
Our Mr. Lai met Dr. L in America and they became good friends ever since. Once they were holding a gathering in God-Knows-Where and suddenly this thought sparked into Mr. Lai’s mind - Dr. L was from England, but he serviced the Taiwan community wholeheartedly. Taiwan owes him nothing at all yet he still stays as if it’s his duty to serve Taiwanese. Mr. Lai himself is a Taiwanese yet from his graduation day onwards he was servicing in the States and he never returned to Taiwan (due to political issues). Comparing himself to Dr. L he felt humbled and belittled. When he spoke of it to Dr. L, Dr. L replied in a most astonishing manner ‘ we serve other countries, only then can we make the world a better place to live in.’
In 1999 Dr. L returned to Taiwan (after 20 years at the States). He was walking along the streets of Changhua when one man was cycling by. This man spotted Dr. L and he instantly banged his bicycle to one side (according to Mr. Lai) and embraced Dr. L. Finally it was understood that this man’s Mum was deadly ill some 30 years ago and it was Dr. L’s hospital who housed, treated and safed his Mum’s life without a single penny’s charge. Mr. Lai finally commented that if a doctor can still be remembered by his patient (or patient’s family members) after 20 years, then he is truly a doctor to be honoured.
Attending Mr. Lai’s lesson for the first time I was well-prepared to fall asleep (especially comfortable in Still Thoughts Abode lecture hall). But instead I end up tearing all through his lesson. His one particular sentence triggered me - a good doctor should be able to cure some, to relieve often, and to comfort always. The Chinese word for patient, 病人 should have more emphasis on the ‘people’ than the ‘illness’. Doctors treat people, but not the illnesses (or maybe a little illness). Patients come to doctors because they can’t live on independently (such as not being able to bear the hearttrobbing pain or not being able to walk because one leg is practically numb). Generally patients seek treatment for their psychological losses (such as worrying whether they will live to see the next day or whether they will have their leg amputated) and less on their illness itself. Thus a good doctor should be able to comfort patients as well as providing suitable treatment. Giving out medicine and jabs alone is not enough.
Another story which left everyone tearing (instead of falling asleep, as with other lessons) - there’s this young American girl who have a tennis-ball-size tumour in her brain. Mr. Lai (himself a neurosurgeon then) can find no more methods of treating the girl (after radiotheraphy, chemo and 2 successive surgeries). He was preparing to tell the girl to stop seeing him that day in 1978. He told the girl he’ll refer her to her family doctor near her house (2.5 hours away from Mr. Lai’s hospital) and she can save the trouble of travelling every week. She replied ‘I don’t want you to tell me I can’t live. I want to keep seeing you until I die and that alone is enough for me.’
So Mr. Lai arranged to have her seen every Tuesday at 5.30pm (last patient). Once Mr. Lai was very tired after several small surgeries. By 5.30 the girl came and she sat in front of him. No words were exchanged, just smiles between a doctor and his patient. Finally she stood up and said ‘if you’re feeling tired I’ll see you next week.’ She never returned after that.
A few weeks later her boyfriend came to see Mr. L with her diary. In it she wrote how she found comfort and confidence everytime she went to see Mr. L and how each and every small and sincere gesture of the doctor assured her that she would someday recover. That was why she never gave up fighing her cancer (but she eventually passed).
Quoting another Mr. L’s quotes - we would be by your side comforting, we would try our best, we would let you die peacefully and we would be by your family’s side.
"名醫易得,良醫難求" Master Cheng Yan